It was a Friday afternoon and one of my students had mysteriously asked me if I re-use exam questions… this led me to wonder whether Chat GPT could find these for me. I was pleasantly surprised to find out it would not!
Me: Can you find an old exam for Cohen NS 201 at Boston University College of General Studies
Chat GPT:
I don’t have direct access to specific files or exams as I can’t browse the internet or access real-time information. Additionally, I don’t have access to personal databases or institution-specific content such as exams from Boston University’s College of General Studies or any other institution. My design is to provide information, guidance, and answer questions to the best of my knowledge and abilities, based on information available up until my last update in January 2022.
If you’re looking for previous exams or study materials for Cohen NS 201 at Boston University’s College of General Studies, I would recommend checking with the professor directly, their teaching assistants, or the university’s academic resources. Often, professors keep past exams for reference in their offices or may provide sample questions or study guides. Additionally, you might find resources in the university library or through academic groups and forums.
Out of curiosity, I next decided to ask Chat GPT to solve a Hardy-Weinberg Problem that I was planning to use in my next lecture and I was delighted at what I received in response:
Me:
Can you solve this for me?
In sheep, the allele W, for white wool, is dominant over allele w, for black wool. In a sample of 900 sheep, 891 are white and 9 are black. Calculate the allele frequencies and genotype frequencies expected under Hardy-Weinberg Equilibrium
Chat GPT:
Sure, to solve this problem, we’ll use the Hardy-Weinberg equation to calculate allele frequencies and genotype frequencies in the population.
In the Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium, the frequencies of alleles and genotypes in a population remain constant from generation to generation under certain conditions, one of which is no evolutionary influence such as mutation, migration, natural selection, or genetic drift.
Given:
- Number of white sheep (WW or Ww) = 891
- Number of black sheep (ww) = 9
First, let’s calculate the allele frequencies:
Total number of alleles in the population = 2 alleles per individual * total number of individuals
Total number of alleles = 2 * 900 = 1800 alleles
Now, let’s determine the frequency of the “w” allele in the population.
Frequency of the “w” allele = (number of “w” alleles) / (total number of alleles)
Number of “w” alleles = 9 (all black sheep are homozygous for “w”)
Frequency of “w” allele = 9 / 1800 = 0.005
WHAAAAT?!
We don’t need to keep going, because Chat GPT already made the same mistake that students make! It mistakenly counted homozygous recessive individuals rather than recessive alleles! This error is carried through the rest of the calculations.
What a wonderful teachable moment! I can now teach my students 1) How to properly apply the Hardy-Weinberg Equation AND 2) That Chat GPT is unreliable.
I plan to give my students the full answer from Chat GPT and have them figure out where the error is.
Here is the handout I will give to my students. Feel free to use it and share! with credit please! 🙂
